Skip to content

South Carolina’s Pension Debt Explosion: Who Could Have Stopped it?

Let’s keep this short.

Who could have stopped our state retirement system from accumulating the $24 billion unfunded liability (debt owed to state workers) that looms over us now?

The five elected officials who formed the old Budget and Control Board.

What five elected officials are we talking about?

The pre-2014 Budget and Control Board consisted of the Governor, Treasurer, Comptroller General, Chairman of Senate Finance Committee and Chairman of House Ways & Means Committee.

Why should they be held accountable?

They were the trustees of the state retirement system for most of the last 20 years. As trustees, they┬áreceived an actuarial report every year that spelled out the unfunded liability for that year and the unfunded liability accumulated to date. How often did they seriously discuss the growing debt in any one of their ten meetings held each year? Spread over 20 years, that’s 200 opportunities.

How much has the unfunded liability grown over 20 years?

The unfunded liability in the 1995-1996 fiscal year was under $1.7 billion. The plan was almost 89% funded then. It is less than 60% funded now.

How did the growing debt impact each state budget going back 20 years?

The unfunded liability was unseen to the general public and not generally understood by most people as actual debt. The amounts that should have been deposited each year into the retirement system to keep it funded at the 89% level were spent on other projects in the state budget.

How can the old trustees be held accountable?

They probably can’t be; at least not on a state level. If they had been trustees of a private retirement system, the DOL and IRS would have held them responsible long before now. Diverting private pension funds away from a plan for personal gain is a crime. Since our five amigos were trustees of a state plan, they answered only to themselves.

One Comment

  1. Peter Thompson

    Do like other businesses do. Stop making pension promises that can’t be met. Renegotiate or cut to pennies on the dollar. Something. The rest of us in the working world have to live on our income. It is not right to not only overpay them for the same job in the public realm, but also make pension promises that are way beyond what we have. Your remedy better not be to tax us more. That is what they do in North Korea: rob the people so government workers can have. It’s not right!

Comments are closed.